If you feel there are any errors in these records, or additions/corrections to be made, please contact oldcollegians@scotch.sa.edu.au.
* denotes Premiership season
| Year | Division | Winner |
|---|---|---|
| 1986 | A2 (A's) | Peter Holder |
| 1987 | A8 (C's) | Steve Boland |
| 1988 | A2 (A's) | Darren Flew |
| 1989 | A2 Res (B's) | Scott Measday |
| 1990 | A1 (A's) | David Williams |
| 1991 | A8 Res (D's) | Stuart Horlin-Smith |
| 1992 | A1 Res (B's) | Sam Nairn |
| 1993 | A8 (C's) | Anthony Coles |
| 1994 | A2 (A's) | Ian Steel |
| 1995 | A3 (A's) | Clay Chaplin |
| 1996 | A1 (A's) | Rob Popplestone |
| 1997 | D3 (A's) / D3 (B's) | Todd Dunow / Mark Kempe |
| 1998 | D2 (A's) | Kent Walker |
| 1999 | D2 Res (B's) | James Dougherty |
| 2000 | D2 (A's) | Todd Dunow |
| 2001 | D2 (A's) | Tim Cosh |
| 2002 | D2 (A's) | Rick Champion |
| 2003 | D9 (C's) | Clay Chaplin |
| 2004 | D2 (A's) | Henry Bourne |
| 2005 | D2 (A's) | Sam Stranks |
| 2006 | D2 (A's) | Rick Champion |
| 2007 | D2 (A's) | Will Smallacombe |
| 2008 | D2 (A's) | Matthew Loukes |
| 2009 | D3 (A's) | Adam Bolton |
| 2010 | D3 (A's) | Cameron Thorpe |
| 2011 | D4 (A's) | Daniel Cahill |
| 2012 | D4 (A's) | Don Nicolson |
| 2013 | D3 (A's) | Nick Brewer |
| 2014 | D2 (A's) | Paul Cahill |
| 2015 | D2 (A's) | Scott Spriggs |
| 2016 | D2 (A's) | Will Thorpe |
| 2017 | D2 (A's) | Shane McAdam |
| 2018 | D3 (A's) | Peter Rolfe |
| 2019 | D2 (A's) | Jy Farrar |
| 2020 | D2 (A's) | Peter Rolfe |
| 2021 | D2 (A's) | Max Marslen |
| 2022 | D3 (A's) | Charlie Morgan |
| 2023 | D3 (A's) | Sam Nehme |
| 2024 | D3 (A's) | Eddie Bok |